Skip to main content

How should we compare creative proposals when they include different work and revision assumptions?

Compare creative proposals using the same brief, then reconcile deliverables, revisions, leadership, capacity and work left with your team.

Written by Remon Geyser

Compare creative proposals against one shared work package before comparing the fees. Two proposals for “a campaign” may cover different creative decisions, deliverables, revision work and client responsibilities.

Use the same representative brief for every provider, then reconcile these differences:

  • Starting point: approved concept and copy, or research, messaging and concept development still required?

  • Output: original assets versus adaptations, quantities, formats and editable-file requirements.

  • Leadership: who shapes the approach, selects specialists and reviews creative quality?

  • Revisions: what feedback is included, what counts as a changed brief and how either affects cost and timing.

  • Capacity: what can run together and what must wait in a queue.

  • Other costs: licensing, filming, development, printing or additional specialist work relevant to this brief.

Mark each item included, excluded or still unclear. An exclusion is not automatically a problem, but its cost and owner belong in the comparison. Keep internal briefing and approval effort visible too; a lower provider fee can leave more work with your team.

Designity is a premium, AI-enabled and human-led Creative-as-a-Service platform. Its dedicated Creative Director leads strategy and quality, while a Creative Project Manager coordinates delivery. Evaluate that managed support against the actual workload the quoted plan can accommodate. Requests and revisions are prioritized within available capacity and active-project limits, not unlimited simultaneous output.

Use current Designity plan details alongside a scoped proposal, rather than treating a monthly fee as a fixed number of completed assets.

Did this answer your question?