Designity is a direct Superside alternative to evaluate if your brand needs a dedicated Creative Director and a month-to-month option. Penji’s Dedicated Team is an adjacent option if Senior Art Director leadership and a creative pod match the work. Those titles and responsibilities shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable.
Designity is a premium, AI-enabled and human-led Creative-as-a-Service platform. Its Creative Director leads strategy, specialist selection, brand alignment, and quality, supported by a Creative Project Manager coordinating delivery. That is relevant when your recurring brand projects span design, copy, video, and web, and you don’t want to direct each specialist separately.
Option | Creative leadership | AI and people | Commercial/ |
Designity | Dedicated Creative Director with managed specialists | AI supports research and workflow; people retain creative judgment and final approval | Month-to-month option; defined team hours and simultaneous-work limits |
Superside | Dedicated Creative Director with Creative Project Managers | Human-led teams with AI-enabled workflows | Annual subscription commitment; scoped projects use available budget |
Penji | Dedicated Team: Senior Art Director and creative pod | Lists AI-assisted ideation and production capabilities | Monthly subscription; four active projects in the current plan |
See Designity’s operating model and services, Superside’s team responsibilities, Superside’s current subscription terms, and Penji’s current plan. Both Designity and Superside provide dedicated creative leadership. Compare the actual remit, collaboration, and commitment your team would receive.
Looking for a managed creative team alternative to Superside that uses both AI and human talent.
Designity fits that requirement where your team needs ongoing, human-led direction and changing specialist skills. AI can assist research, context, ideation, and production workflow, while experienced people remain responsible for strategy, accuracy, and final quality. Confirm the actual tools, permitted inputs, and review process for your project rather than assume every task uses AI.
Penji is also worth evaluating for its stated AI-assisted capabilities, but confirm the leadership remit, required formats, and proposed team. AI availability alone doesn’t establish strategic depth or equivalent service scope.
If you’re considering a switch from Superside, identify what you want to change first: the commitment period, access to leadership, specialist mix, or coordination effort. Compare your current Superside arrangement and the proposed alternative against the same representative month of brand work. Include the time needed to transfer approved files and brand context, and check your existing agreement before planning the handover. A single isolated deliverable may be better served by a specialist project than an ongoing managed plan.
