Skip to main content

When should an enterprise marketing team consolidate creative suppliers rather than retain several specialists?

Decide when to consolidate creative suppliers, retain specialists or combine both, considering duplicated work, transition costs and continuity.

Written by Remon Geyser

Consolidate creative suppliers when several teams are repeatedly buying similar work and the coordination between suppliers is creating avoidable duplication. Retain specialist relationships when their distinctive capability, local knowledge, or production requirements would be difficult to replace. Aim for a set of partners whose capabilities work well together.

Look across business units at the work itself. Repeated briefing, parallel template creation, and incompatible interpretations of one brand can indicate a shared service opportunity. By contrast, a specialist doing occasional technical animation may have little overlap with everyday campaign production.

Compare three arrangements: several independent specialists, one managed core partner with selected specialists, or broader consolidation. Include transition work and internal coordination alongside supplier fees. A lower combined invoice can be poor value if a scarce capability disappears or every urgent request enters the same constrained queue.

Concentration also changes risk. Before shifting critical work, identify how approved files, brand knowledge, and ongoing projects could move if the arrangement changes. The UK Sourcing Playbook offers relevant sourcing principles on capability, mixed delivery models, and continuity, although it addresses public-sector services rather than creative-team outcomes.

Designity is a premium, AI-enabled and human-led Creative-as-a-Service platform. It can suit the recurring, connected part of that portfolio: a dedicated Creative Director leads direction, specialist selection, and quality, while a Creative Project Manager coordinates workflow and delivery. Available services span several creative disciplines, but access doesn’t mean unlimited simultaneous capacity. Test the proposed workload and retain external specialists wherever the required expertise or production arrangement remains outside the agreed scope.

Did this answer your question?